| | | Methodist wins toss, defers to second half. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu35 | MU ball on MU40. |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 48 yards to the LC12, Nick Simmons return 16 yards to the LC28 (Latovis Davis). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc28 | Aaron Duncan rush for 3 yards to the LC31 (Jonath Fulmore.). |
| Lc | 2-7 | at Lc31 | Marquius Young rush for 3 yards to the LC34 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 3-4 | at Lc34 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to Aaron Duncan, dropped pass. |
| Lc | 4-4 | at Lc34 | Drake Nahrwold punt 35 yards to the MU31, Vaughn Cross return 18 yards to the MU49 (Nathan Mathis;Michael May). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu49 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:07. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu49 | Max Reber pass intercepted by Andre Carter at the LC47, Andre Carter return 23 yards to the MU30 (Vaughn Cross). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu30 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 12:57. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu30 | Kent Gibson rush for 2 yards to the MU28 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 2-8 | at Mu28 | Jo Jo Sweet rush for 1 yard to the MU27 (Seth Sandlin). |
| Lc | 3-7 | at Mu27 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to Cody Darracott, dropped pass. |
| Lc | 4-7 | at Mu27 | Ed Russ sacked for loss of 12 yards to the MU39 (Brad Wade). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 01:19 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu39 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 11:38. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu39 | John Pappillion rush for no gain to the MU39 (Andre Carter;Zach Inman). |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Mu39 | Max Reber pass complete to Vaughn Cross for 9 yards to the MU48 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 3-1 | at Mu48 | John Pappillion rush for no gain to the MU48 (Klay Cranford;Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 4-1 | at Mu48 | Max Reber punt 39 yards to the LC13, fair catch by R.J. Miles. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc13 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 09:30. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc13 | Kent Gibson rush for 7 yards to the LC20 (Bryan Bing;Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 2-3 | at Lc20 | Aaron Duncan rush for 4 yards to the LC24, 1ST DOWN LC (Bryan Bing;Roy Mewborn). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc24 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to Aaron Duncan. |
| Lc | 2-10 | at Lc24 | Ed Russ rush for 3 yards to the LC27 (Navahri Holden;Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 3-7 | at Lc27 | Ed Russ pass complete to Aaron Duncan for 8 yards to the LC35, 1ST DOWN LC. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc35 | Kent Gibson rush for no gain to the LC35 (Navahri Holden;M.J. Bryant), PENALTY LC illegal block (Aaron Duncan) 15 yards to the LC20, NO PLAY. |
| Lc | 1-25 | at Lc20 | PENALTY LC false start (Scottie Connors) 5 yards to the LC15. |
| Lc | 1-30 | at Lc15 | Ed Russ rush for 85 yards to the MU0, 1ST DOWN LC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:30. |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kick attempt good. |
| | | LaGrange College 7, Methodist University 0 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 87 yards, TOP 03:00 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 55 yards to the MU10, downed. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu10 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 06:30. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu10 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MU3 (Justin McIntyre). |
| Mu | 2-17 | at Mu03 | John Flanagan rush for loss of 2 yards to the MU1 (Andre Carter;Justin McIntyre). |
| Mu | 3-19 | at Mu01 | Max Reber rush for no gain to the MU1 (Justin Roper;Tyler Johnson). |
| Mu | 4-19 | at Mu01 | Max Reber punt 41 yards to the MU42, R.J. Miles return to the MU30, PENALTY LC roughing the kicker (Andre Carter) 15 yards to the MU16, 1ST DOWN MU, NO PLAY. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu16 | Max Reber pass complete to Vaughn Cross for loss of 2 yards to the MU14 (P.G. Standard). |
| Mu | 2-12 | at Mu14 | John Flanagan rush for loss of 1 yard to the MU13 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 3-13 | at Mu13 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross. |
| Mu | 4-13 | at Mu13 | Max Reber punt 25 yards to the MU38, fair catch by R.J. Miles. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 3 yards, TOP 03:50 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu38 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 02:40. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu38 | Ed Russ pass incomplete (Antjuan Jones), QB hurry by Antjuan Jones. |
| Lc | 2-10 | at Mu38 | Ed Russ pass complete to R.J. Miles for no gain to the MU38 (Kel Richardson.). |
| Lc | 3-10 | at Mu38 | Ed Russ pass intercepted by Roy Mewborn at the MU25, Roy Mewborn return 22 yards to the MU47 (John John Hill). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu47 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:48. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu47 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 6 yards to the MU41 (Daniel Garrett). |
| Mu | 2-16 | at Mu41 | Max Reber rush for loss of 11 yards to the MU30, fumble by Max Reber recovered by MU John Flanagan at MU30. |
| Mu | 3-27 | at Mu30 | Max Reber rush for 13 yards to the MU43 (Daniel Garrett). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| | | LaGrange College 7, Methodist University 0 |
| Mu | 4-14 | at Mu43 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mu | 4-14 | at Mu43 | Max Reber punt 27 yards to the LC30, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc30 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 14:51. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc30 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 1 yard to the LC29 (Bryan Bing;Jonath Fulmore.). |
| Lc | 2-11 | at Lc29 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 6 yards to the LC23 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 3-17 | at Lc23 | Ed Russ pass incomplete, QB hurry by M.J. Bryant. |
| Lc | 4-17 | at Lc23 | Drake Nahrwold punt 31 yards to the MU46, Kel Richardson. return 2 yards to the MU48 (R.J. Miles;Justin McIntyre). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu48 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:10. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu48 | Max Reber rush for loss of 7 yards to the MU41, fumble by Max Reber recovered by MU Max Reber at MU41. |
| Mu | 2-17 | at Mu41 | Max Reber pass complete to Patrick Jacobs for 8 yards to the MU49 (Anthony Cochran). |
| Mu | 3-9 | at Mu49 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Patrick Jacobs (Anthony Cochran), PENALTY LC pass interference (Anthony Cochran) 15 yards to the LC36, 1ST DOWN MU, NO PLAY. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc36 | Darius Page rush for 29 yards to the LC7, 1ST DOWN MU (Chris Vernet;Marq. Abernathy). |
| Mu | 1-G | at Lc07 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 6 yards to the LC13 (Klay Cranford). |
| Mu | 2-G | at Lc13 | Max Reber rush for 5 yards to the LC8 (Justin Roper;Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 3-G | at Lc08 | Max Reber pass complete to Vaughn Cross for 8 yards to the LC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:51. |
| | | Cody Ausherman kick attempt good. |
| | | Methodist University 7, LaGrange College 7 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 52 yards, TOP 03:25 |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 55 yards to the LC10, downed, PENALTY LC illegal block (Nick Raszeja) 5 yards to the LC5, 1st and 10, LC ball on LC5. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc05 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 09:45. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc05 | Michael Jones rush for 2 yards to the LC7 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 2-8 | at Lc07 | Michael Jones rush for loss of 4 yards to the LC3 (Brad Wade;Latovis Davis). |
| Lc | 3-12 | at Lc03 | Michael Jones rush for loss of 2 yards to the LC1 (Antonio Jackson). |
| Lc | 4-14 | at Lc01 | Drake Nahrwold punt 28 yards to the LC29, Vaughn Cross return 8 yards to the LC21 (Chris Vernet). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc21 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:35. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc21 | Max Reber pass incomplete to James Bevans. |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Lc21 | Max Reber pass complete to James Bevans for 1 yard to the LC20 (Daniel Garrett). |
| Mu | 3-9 | at Lc20 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross. |
| Mu | 4-9 | at Lc20 | Cody Ausherman field goal attempt from 37 GOOD, clock 06:38. |
| | | Methodist University 10, LaGrange College 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 64 yards to the LC1, Kent Gibson return 36 yards to the LC37 (Latovis Davis), PENALTY MU Encroachment 5 yards to the LC42, 1st and 10, LC ball on LC42. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc42 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 06:27. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc42 | Ed Russ pass complete to Aaron Duncan for loss of 4 yards to the LC38 (Antjuan Jones). |
| Lc | 2-14 | at Lc38 | Kent Gibson rush for no gain to the LC38 (Brad Wade). |
| Lc | 3-14 | at Lc38 | Ed Russ rush for 25 yards to the MU37, 1ST DOWN LC (Malcolm McCoy), PENALTY MU sideline interference 15 yards to the MU22, 1ST DOWN LC. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu22 | 1st and 10. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu22 | Ed Russ rush for no gain to the MU22 (Bryan Bing;J.D. Stalvey). |
| Lc | 2-10 | at Mu22 | Kent Gibson rush for 22 yards to the MU0, 1ST DOWN LC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:13. |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kick attempt good. |
| | | LaGrange College 14, Methodist University 10 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 58 yards, TOP 02:22 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 55 yards to the MU10, Terrell Walker return 11 yards to the MU21. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu21 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 04:05. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu21 | John Flanagan rush for no gain to the MU21 (Daniel Garrett;Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Mu21 | Max Reber pass complete to James Bevans for 4 yards to the MU25 (Marq. Abernathy). |
| Mu | 3-6 | at Mu25 | Max Reber rush for 4 yards to the MU29 (Corneil. Harper;Emory Wingard). |
| Mu | 4-2 | at Mu29 | Max Reber punt 44 yards to the LC27, R.J. Miles return 0 yards to the LC27 (Shaqu Nuriddin.). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc27 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 02:16. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc27 | Kent Gibson rush for 3 yards to the LC30 (Jonath Fulmore.). |
| Lc | 2-7 | at Lc30 | Kent Gibson rush for 6 yards to the LC36 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 3-1 | at Lc36 | Kent Gibson rush for 2 yards to the LC38, 1ST DOWN LC (M.J. Bryant;Navahri Holden). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc38 | Ed Russ sacked for loss of 8 yards to the LC30 (Brad Wade). |
| Lc | 2-18 | at Lc30 | Timeout LaGrange College, clock 00:43. |
| Lc | 2-18 | at Lc30 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to John John Hill, dropped pass. |
| Lc | 3-18 | at Lc30 | Ed Russ rush for 19 yards to the LC49, 1ST DOWN LC (Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc49 | Timeout LaGrange College, clock 00:29. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc49 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to John John Hill. |
| Lc | 2-10 | at Lc49 | Ed Russ sacked for loss of 8 yards to the LC41 (Kel Richardson.). |
| Lc | 3-18 | at Lc41 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | LaGrange College 14, Methodist University 10 |
| Lc | 3-18 | at Lc41 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, LC ball on LC35. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 64 yards to the MU1, Vaughn Cross return 8 yards to the MU9. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu09 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:53. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu09 | Vaughn Cross rush for loss of 2 yards to the MU7 (P.G. Standard). |
| Mu | 2-12 | at Mu07 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 1 yard to the MU6 (Corneil. Harper). |
| Mu | 3-13 | at Mu06 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Gerry Gillis. |
| Mu | 4-13 | at Mu06 | Max Reber punt 31 yards to the MU37, fair catch by R.J. Miles. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu37 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 13:23. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu37 | Kent Gibson rush for 3 yards to the MU34 (Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 2-7 | at Mu34 | Ed Russ rush for 8 yards to the MU26, 1ST DOWN LC (Bryan Bing;Antjuan Jones). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu26 | Kent Gibson rush for 2 yards to the MU24 (Antjuan Jones;M.J. Bryant), PENALTY MU face mask (Antjuan Jones) 12 yards to the MU12, 1ST DOWN LC. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu12 | 1st and 10. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu12 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 1 yard to the MU13 (Jonath Fulmore.;M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 2-11 | at Mu13 | Ed Russ rush for 1 yard to the MU12 (Brad Wade;Antjuan Jones). |
| Lc | 3-10 | at Mu12 | Ed Russ pass complete to R.J. Miles for 7 yards to the MU5 (Roy Mewborn;Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 4-3 | at Mu05 | Will Jeffcoat field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 09:48. |
| | | LaGrange College 17, Methodist University 10 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 32 yards, TOP 03:35 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 65 yards to the MU0, touchback. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu25 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:48. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu25 | Max Reber rush for loss of 4 yards to the MU21 (Justin Roper;Tyler Johnson). |
| Mu | 2-14 | at Mu21 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross. |
| Mu | 3-14 | at Mu21 | Max Reber pass intercepted by Anthony Cochran at the MU40, Anthony Cochran return 0 yards to the MU40. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:50 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu40 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 08:58. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu40 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 5 yards to the MU45 (Jacob Hunt;Andrew Davis). |
| Lc | 2-15 | at Mu45 | Ed Russ pass complete to R.J. Miles for 11 yards to the MU34 (Malcolm McCoy). |
| Lc | 3-4 | at Mu34 | Ed Russ pass complete to Ezekiel Grogan for 7 yards to the MU27, 1ST DOWN LC (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu27 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to R.J. Miles, dropped pass. |
| Lc | 2-10 | at Mu27 | Ed Russ rush for 12 yards to the MU15, 1ST DOWN LC (Andrew Davis;Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu15 | Kent Gibson rush for 4 yards to the MU11 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 2-6 | at Mu11 | Ed Russ rush for 2 yards to the MU9 (Roy Mewborn;Jonathan Vita). |
| Lc | 3-4 | at Mu09 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to Aaron Duncan. |
| Lc | 4-4 | at Mu09 | Will Jeffcoat field goal attempt from 26 GOOD, clock 05:13. |
| | | LaGrange College 20, Methodist University 10 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 31 yards, TOP 03:49 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 65 yards to the MU0, touchback. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu25 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:09. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu25 | John Pappillion rush for 2 yards to the MU27 (Shaun Nichols). |
| Mu | 2-8 | at Mu27 | John Pappillion rush for 3 yards to the MU30. |
| Mu | 3-5 | at Mu30 | Max Reber rush for 5 yards to the MU35, 1ST DOWN MU (Corneil. Harper). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu35 | John Pappillion rush for no gain to the MU35 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Mu35 | Max Reber pass complete to Ricky Brayboy for 7 yards to the MU42 (P.G. Standard). |
| Mu | 3-3 | at Mu42 | Max Reber pass complete to Ricky Brayboy for 3 yards to the MU45, 1ST DOWN MU (Anthony Cochran), PENALTY LC roughing passer (Justin Roper) 15 yards to the LC40, 1ST DOWN MU. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc40 | 1st and 10. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc40 | Max Reber pass incomplete to John Pappillion (Corneil. Harper). |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Lc40 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross (Chris Vernet). |
| Mu | 3-10 | at Lc40 | Max Reber pass complete to Adam Thomas for 12 yards to the LC28, 1ST DOWN MU. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc28 | Max Reber rush for 12 yards to the LC16, 1ST DOWN MU (Arno. Jefferson). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc16 | John Pappillion rush for 1 yard to the LC15 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 2-9 | at Lc15 | Max Reber pass complete to John Pappillion for loss of 2 yards to the LC17 (Corneil. Harper). |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 58 yards, TOP 05:30 |
| | | LaGrange College 20, Methodist University 10 |
| Mu | 3-11 | at Lc17 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mu | 3-11 | at Lc17 | Max Reber pass incomplete to James Bevans. |
| Mu | 4-11 | at Lc17 | Cody Ausherman field goal attempt from 34 GOOD, clock 14:48. |
| | | LaGrange College 20, Methodist University 13 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 58 yards, TOP 05:30 |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 65 yards to the LC0, Kent Gibson return 27 yards to the LC27 (Patr Truesdell.). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc27 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 14:39. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc27 | Ed Russ rush for 9 yards to the LC36 (Bryan Bing;J.D. Stalvey). |
| Lc | 2-1 | at Lc36 | Kent Gibson rush for no gain to the LC36 (Jonath Fulmore.). |
| Lc | 3-1 | at Lc36 | Ed Russ rush for 3 yards to the LC39, 1ST DOWN LC (Navahri Holden). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Lc39 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to John John Hill, PENALTY MU pass interference (Malcolm McCoy) 14 yards to the MU47, 1ST DOWN LC, NO PLAY. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu47 | Ed Russ rush for 9 yards to the MU38 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 2-1 | at Mu38 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 1 yard to the MU39 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 3-2 | at Mu39 | PENALTY MU Encroachment (Brad Wade) 5 yards to the MU34, 1ST DOWN LC. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu34 | Jo Jo Sweet rush for 1 yard to the MU33 (Roy Mewborn). |
| Lc | 2-9 | at Mu33 | Kent Gibson rush for 8 yards to the MU25 (Roy Mewborn;Kel Richardson.). |
| Lc | 3-1 | at Mu25 | Kent Gibson rush for 2 yards to the MU23, 1ST DOWN LC (Navahri Holden;J.D. Stalvey). |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu23 | Ed Russ rush for 3 yards to the MU20 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 2-7 | at Mu20 | Kent Gibson rush for no gain to the MU20 (Navahri Holden;Kel Richardson.). |
| Lc | 3-7 | at Mu20 | Ed Russ pass complete to Ezekiel Grogan for 16 yards to the MU4, 1ST DOWN LC. |
| Lc | 1-G | at Mu04 | Ed Russ rush for no gain to the MU4 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 2-G | at Mu04 | Kent Gibson rush for 1 yard to the MU3 (Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 3-G | at Mu03 | Ed Russ pass incomplete to Kent Gibson. |
| Lc | 4-G | at Mu03 | Will Jeffcoat field goal attempt from 20 GOOD, clock 07:18. |
| | | LaGrange College 23, Methodist University 13 |
| | | Drive: 15 plays, 70 yards, TOP 07:21 |
| | | Will Jeffcoat kickoff 47 yards to the MU18, Blake Scott return 0 yards to the MU18. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu18 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:18. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu18 | John Flanagan rush for 6 yards to the MU24 (Anthony Cochran), PENALTY MU illegal block (Adam Thomas) 6 yards to the MU12, NO PLAY. |
| Mu | 1-16 | at Mu12 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Patrick Jacobs. |
| Mu | 2-16 | at Mu12 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 8 yards to the MU4 (Justin McIntyre), fumble by Max Reber recovered by MU John Flanagan at MU4. |
| Mu | 3-24 | at Mu04 | John Flanagan rush for 4 yards to the MU8 (Tyler Johnson). |
| Mu | 4-20 | at Mu08 | Max Reber punt 36 yards to the MU44, fair catch by R.J. Miles. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu44 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 05:45. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu44 | Kent Gibson rush for 9 yards to the MU35 (M.J. Bryant). |
| Lc | 2-1 | at Mu35 | Timeout Methodist University, clock 05:35. |
| Lc | 2-1 | at Mu35 | Ed Russ rush for loss of 2 yards to the MU37 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 3-3 | at Mu37 | Timeout Methodist University, clock 05:30. |
| Lc | 3-3 | at Mu37 | Daniel Staples rush for loss of 7 yards to the MU44 (Bryan Bing). |
| Lc | 4-10 | at Mu44 | Timeout Methodist University, clock 05:24. |
| Lc | 4-10 | at Mu44 | Drake Nahrwold punt 35 yards to the MU9, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:30 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu09 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:15. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu09 | Max Reber pass complete to James Bevans for 15 yards to the MU24, 1ST DOWN MU (Arno. Jefferson). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu24 | Max Reber rush for 8 yards to the MU32, out-of-bounds. |
| Mu | 2-2 | at Mu32 | Max Reber pass complete to James Bevans for 16 yards to the MU48, 1ST DOWN MU (Marq. Abernathy;P.G. Standard). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu48 | Max Reber pass complete to Adam Thomas for 11 yards to the LC41, 1ST DOWN MU (Chris Vernet). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc41 | Max Reber pass incomplete to James Bevans. |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Lc41 | Max Reber pass complete to John Flanagan for 11 yards to the LC30, 1ST DOWN MU (Anthony Cochran). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc30 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 8 yards to the LC38 (Andre Carter), fumble by Max Reber recovered by MU C.J. Maxwell at LC38. |
| Mu | 2-18 | at Lc38 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross, PENALTY LC pass interference (Chris Vernet) 15 yards to the LC23, 1ST DOWN MU, NO PLAY. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc23 | Max Reber pass complete to Vaughn Cross for 23 yards to the LC0, 1ST DOWN MU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:04. |
| | | Cody Ausherman kick attempt good. |
| | | LaGrange College 23, Methodist University 20 |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 12 yards to the MU47, on-side kick, recovered by LC on MU47, PENALTY LC offside 5 yards to the MU40, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 91 yards, TOP 02:15 |
| | | Cody Ausherman kickoff 8 yards to the MU48, on-side kick, recovered by LC on MU48, PENALTY MU offside 5 yards to the MU43, 1st and 10, LC ball on MU43. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu43 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 03:00. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu43 | Kent Gibson rush for 1 yard to the MU42 (Jonath Fulmore.). |
| Lc | 2-9 | at Mu42 | Kent Gibson rush for 4 yards to the MU38 (Roy Mewborn). |
| Lc | 3-5 | at Mu38 | Kent Gibson rush for 1 yard to the MU37 (Seth Sandlin). |
| Lc | 4-4 | at Mu37 | Kent Gibson rush for 1 yard to the MU36 (Bryan Bing). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 7 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu36 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:57. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu36 | Max Reber pass incomplete to Vaughn Cross (Chris Vernet). |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Mu36 | Max Reber sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MU29 (Emory Wingard). |
| Mu | 3-17 | at Mu29 | Max Reber pass complete to Adam Thomas for 20 yards to the MU49, 1ST DOWN MU (Anthony Cochran). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Mu49 | Max Reber pass complete to Adam Thomas for 16 yards to the LC35, 1ST DOWN MU (P.G. Standard). |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc35 | Max Reber pass incomplete. |
| Mu | 2-10 | at Lc35 | Max Reber pass complete to George Adams for 7 yards to the LC28 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 3-3 | at Lc28 | Max Reber pass incomplete. |
| Mu | 4-3 | at Lc28 | Cody Ausherman field goal attempt from 45 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| | | Methodist University 23, LaGrange College 23 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 36 yards, TOP 00:57 |
| | | Methodist University 23, LaGrange College 23 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Methodist University 26, LaGrange College 23 |
| Mu | 1-G | at Mu35 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mu | 1-G | at Mu35 | Change of possession, LC ball on MU25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 36 yards, TOP 00:57 |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu25 | LAGRANGE COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Lc | 1-10 | at Mu25 | Kent Gibson rush for loss of 1 yard to the MU26 (M.J. Bryant;Jacob Hunt). |
| Lc | 2-11 | at Mu26 | Ed Russ rush for 1 yard to the MU25 (Antjuan Jones;B.J. Minter). |
| Lc | 3-10 | at Mu25 | Ed Russ sacked for loss of 9 yards to the MU34 (Kel Richardson.). |
| Lc | 4-19 | at Mu34 | Timeout Methodist University, clock 15:00. |
| Lc | 4-19 | at Mu34 | Will Jeffcoat field goal attempt from 51 MISSED - short, spot at LC25, clock 15:00. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc25 | METHODIST UNIVERSITY drive start at 15:00. |
| Mu | 1-10 | at Lc25 | Max Reber rush for 5 yards to the LC20 (Anthony Cochran). |
| Mu | 2-5 | at Lc20 | John Flanagan rush for 17 yards to the LC3, 1ST DOWN MU (Chris Vernet). |
| Mu | 1-G | at Lc03 | John Flanagan rush for no gain to the LC3 (Zach Inman). |
| Mu | 2-G | at Lc03 | John Flanagan rush for loss of 3 yards to the LC6 (Andre Carter). |
| Mu | 3-G | at Lc06 | Timeout LaGrange College, clock 15:00. |
| Mu | 3-G | at Lc06 | Cody Ausherman field goal attempt from 23 GOOD, clock 15:00. |
| | | Methodist University 26, LaGrange College 23 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Methodist University 26, LaGrange College 23 |