| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Fayetteville, NC | Methodist 10, Christopher Newport 9 | Box score |
| Nov 07, 2009 | Greensboro, NC | Greensboro 42, Methodist 20 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Fayetteville, NC | NC Wesleyan 42, Methodist 32 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Danville, VA | Averett 38, Methodist 7 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Fayetteville, NC | Methodist 17, Shenandoah 14 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Ferrum, VA | Ferrum 49, Methodist 35 | Box score |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Maryville, TN | Maryville College 36, Methodist 30 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Fayetteville, NC | Emory & Henry 28, Methodist 3 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Fayetteville, NC | Methodist 20, Guilford 19 | Box score |
| Sept 5 2009 | Buies Creek, NC | Campbell 48, Methodist 28 | Box score |